Common Wild Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

Pennsylvania’s woodlands are home to a variety of edible and poisonous mushroom species.

Foraging for wild mushrooms can be an enjoyable hobby and a good way to find fresh ingredients, but it also carries risks.

Some toxic mushrooms closely resemble safe, edible varieties.

It is essential to learn how to reliably identify mushrooms before consuming them.

This article explores some of the most notable wild mushrooms found across Pennsylvania, detailing key identification features and when and where they can be found.

Key Takeaways

  • Pennsylvania’s forests and fields offer an abundance of edible wild mushrooms like the king bolete, chanterelle, oyster mushroom and chicken of the woods. With proper identification, they can be excellent additions to many recipes.
  • Extremely poisonous mushrooms like the death cap, destroying angel and fly agaric also grow in Pennsylvania and can be fatal if consumed. Exercise extreme caution when mushroom foraging.
  • Always thoroughly cook wild mushrooms before eating them, as cooking can help deactivate toxins. Some mushrooms closely resemble edible varieties but are poisonous.
  • Only collect mushrooms that can be identified with 100% certainty. If in doubt, do not eat it. Consider joining a mushroom foraging club to learn proper identification from experienced hunters.
  • Take care to cut mushrooms rather than pulling them out of the ground to avoid damaging sensitive mycelium networks. Mushrooms play a crucial role in forest ecosystems.
  • Familiarize yourself with the toxic mushrooms in your region and avoid areas where they are known to grow. Only collect mushrooms from areas free of pesticides, herbicides and pollution.
  • Always forage sustainably and responsibly. Do not take all mushrooms in one area but leave some to disperse spores. Follow all forest regulations on conservation and access.

Edible Mushrooms in Pennsylvania

Boletus Edulis – The King Bolete

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

The Boletus edulis, commonly known as the king bolete, is one of the most coveted wild edible mushrooms.

It has a distinctive bulbous stem and smooth, reddish-brown cap, often growing in a symbiotic relationship with tree roots.

King boletes are found across many regions of Pennsylvania from July to October, especially under oak, pine and birch trees.

They have a mild, nutty flavor and firm texture, making them excellent for sautéing, grilling or adding to soups and stews.

Giant Puffballs – A Versatile Fungus

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

Giant puffballs are one of the most easily identifiable mushrooms.

As their name suggests, they can grow to be very large, over a foot in diameter!

They start out white and firm, then turn yellowish and eventually brown and powdery inside as they mature.

Giant puffballs are versatile edible mushrooms when young and white.

Their mild flavor lends well to recipes like fried mushroom fritters, or they can be sautéed, roasted or used as a meat substitute.

Find them in fields, meadows and grassy areas of Pennsylvania from August to October.

The Delicate Flavor of the Golden Chanterelle

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

With its vibrant yellow-orange hue and distinctive funnel shape, the golden chanterelle is one of the most recognizable edible mushroom species.

It has a fruity, peppery aroma and delicate, smooth flavor that shines when sautéed in butter or oil.

Golden chanterelles can be found near hardwood trees like oak, poplar and beech scattered across the forest floors of Pennsylvania from June to November.

They are more common after periods of heavy rainfall.

Oyster Mushrooms – A Pennsylvania Staple

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

A perennial favorite, oyster mushrooms can be found growing abundantly on decaying hardwood logs and stumps in many parts of Pennsylvania.

They grow in layered, cmsoysterr-shaped clusters ranging from pale yellow to deep brown in color.

With their mild, delicate flavor, oyster mushrooms are a staple ingredient in many soups and stir fry dishes.

They are one of the easiest wild mushrooms to identify for beginners.

Oyster mushrooms fruit from spring through early winter in Pennsylvania’s woodlands.

Chicken of the Woods – A Mushroom that Tastes Like Chicken

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

Chicken of the woods is a brilliant orange-yellow shelflike mushroom that grows in clusters on decaying trees, stumps and logs.

It has a meaty texture and its name comes from its chicken-like flavor when cooked.

Chicken of the woods is one of the best edible mushrooms for beginners to identify.

It can be found from May to November across Pennsylvania.

This versatile mushroom can be sautéed, baked, grilled or used in place of chicken in recipes.

Shaggy Mane – An Excellent Beginner’s Mushroom

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

The shaggy mane, also known as the lawyer’s wig, is an excellent edible mushroom for beginners to identify.

As its name suggests, it has a cylindrical cap that starts out egg-shaped and opens up to resemble a shaggy mane as it matures.

The cap is reddish-brown with whitish scales. Shaggy manes have a rich, earthy flavor and are best eaten when young.

They grow in grassy areas and fields throughout Pennsylvania from August through October.

Poisonous Mushrooms in Pennsylvania

Avoid the Deadly Poison of the Death Cap

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

The death cap mushroom is potentially the most poisonous mushroom in the world.

This deadly fungus has a greenish-yellow cap, white gills and sac-like cup at the base of its stem.

Unfortunately, it bears a close resemblance to edible straw mushrooms and caesar’s mushrooms.

Consuming even a small amount can be fatal due to the amatoxins contained. There is no antidote.

Encounters with the death cap in Pennsylvania occur from July to November, typically in association with hardwood trees.

Extreme caution is advised when mushroom foraging.

Beware the Poisonous Destroying Angel

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

Closely related to the death cap, the destroying angel is another deadly poisonous mushroom that lurks in Pennsylvania forests.

It has a smooth white cap and stem with white gills that can emerge from the ground or at the base of trees.

Consuming any part of this mushroom leads to irreversible liver and kidney damage within 6 to 12 hours.

There is no antidote. Destoying angels grow scattered or in groups from mid summer through autumn.

Extreme caution should be used when foraging for mushrooms.

Fly Agaric – A Poisonous and Psychedelic Mushroom

Common Mushrooms In Pa: Edible & Poisonous

With its distinct red cap and white polka dots, the fly agaric mushroom is instantly recognizable.

It has psychedelic properties and has appeared in many stories, video games and pop culture over the years.

However, the fly agaric is also poisonous due to compounds like muscimol and ibotenic acid.

While rarely deadly, it can cause delirium, vomiting, twitching and loss of coordination in humans and should be avoided.

This iconic mushroom grows near spruce and birch trees in Pennsylvania forests during summer and fall.

Before You Go

If your looking to buy shrubs or trees online, I highly recommend Nature Hills.

They always have sales and discounts on nursery stock, well worth your time checking them out.

You can find them here,

Also, I have other articles about mushrooms in PA that might interest you, you can check them out here.

Types Of Orange Mushrooms In Pennsylvania

Best Place To Find King Boletes In PA

Where Does Chicken Of The Woods Grow In PA

Foraging for Shaggy Mane Mushrooms in Pennsylvania

Best Places to Find Black Trumpet Mushrooms in PA

Foraging for Wild Oyster Mushrooms: Pennsylvania Guide

Pennsylvania Morel Mushroom Hunting Guide.

Other Articles

Plant Grower Report